Notebook XV: Difference between revisions

From Karl Polanyi
Jump to navigation Jump to search
mNo edit summary
Line 49: Line 49:
„Both deny the realism of dialectic, that is three-dimensional, thinking.” 145
„Both deny the realism of dialectic, that is three-dimensional, thinking.” 145


== Theory of the Facist Transformation (continued) ==
== Theory of the Facist Transformation (cont.) ==


{{Page |n°=74}} <u>Theory of fascist Transformation</u> (cont)<br />
{{Page |n°=74}} The influence of the working class a <u>{nuisance} value</u>.
 
The influence of the working class a <u>{nuisance} value</u>.


Positive _____<br />  
Positive _____<br />  
Line 59: Line 57:
b)<br >
b)<br >
c)<br >
c)<br >
d)<br >
d) reforming capitalism of factory <br >


<u>more ______</u>
<u>more ______</u>
Line 73: Line 71:
[…]
[…]


{{Page |n°=76}} […] war theological.
{{Page |n°=76}} […] <u>Karl Marx  war theological</u>.


„Kleanthes” Dialog von 24 B____ eine philosophische-dialektische __________ __ Gottheit…“  
„Kleanthes” Dialog von 24 B____ eine philosophische-dialektische __________ __ Gottheit…“  
Line 79: Line 77:
His _____ ___ ____ theological _______ law, theology, etc.
His _____ ___ ____ theological _______ law, theology, etc.


Hegel […].
Hegel {lapt} die Stände […].


{{Page |n°=77}} <u>Marx on the „Corporative State”</u>
{{Page |n°=77}} <u>Marx on the „Corporative State”</u>
Line 85: Line 83:
There is a Criticism of Marx in the Corporative State which is of very real interest.
There is a Criticism of Marx in the Corporative State which is of very real interest.


It was a _______. We are faced by a ____ view. Fascism […] Hegel
It was a _______. We are faced by a ____ view. Fascism […] to the stage at which Hegel ____ to fix them in the 1820s.


Capitalism was coming, now it is outgoing. But we do not overate …
Capitalism was coming, now it is outgoing. But we do not overate to-day their phases. Capitalism was centuries old, and certainly […]


Hegel gave an
Hegel gave an idealized version of the Prussian State of his time.
 
We do not say that {France} is nothing else but absolutism.


{{Page |n°=78}} <u>Theory of fascist Transformation</u> (cont)
{{Page |n°=78}} <u>Theory of fascist Transformation</u> (cont)
Line 114: Line 114:
b) […]
b) […]


{{Page |n°=80}} à la Hegel + a {materialisation} of the Corporations and States of the Realm. But these are certainly, very close analyses.  
{{Page |n°=80}} à la Hegel + a modernisation of the Corporations and States of the Realm. But these are certainly, very close analyses.  


It is perhaps worthwhile to re-translate Hegel difficult _____ ___ plain English in order to get at the meaning of ___'s command.
It is perhaps worthwhile to re-translate Hegel difficult _____ ___ plain English in order to get at the meaning of ___'s command.
Line 121: Line 121:
political sphere - economic sphere
political sphere - economic sphere


1) Hegel refuses to accept the individual as the wih of the political State.
1) Hegel refuses to accept the individual as the with of the political State.


He prefers the <u>{facial/fascists}</u> and <u>economic life</u> the later as _________ corporations.
He prefers the <u>family</u> and <u>economic life</u> the later as _________ corporations. | Hitlerism insists of family!


The State emerges out of the family and economic life […] of nature out of which the ____ of the State leaps (23)
The State emerges out of the family and economic life […] of nature out of which the ____ of the State leaps (23)
Line 130: Line 130:


Two ______ of balance: […]
Two ______ of balance: […]
a) political system must be sufficiently workable (extreme cases! […]


{{Page |n°=83}} When Hegel []
a) England


First: What does Hegel say: family and economic life are stated to be that […]
b) Germany …
 
c) Italy: …
 
d) Austria …
 
e) Poland: … […]
 
{{Page |n°=83}} When Hegel in his curious phenomenology makes the family and the economic life are the two  […]
 
First: What does Hegel say: family and economic life are stated to be the two ”____ into which the real … […]


What about the {individualized}  
What about the {individualized}  
Line 143: Line 154:
<u>I In search of a starting point</u>
<u>I In search of a starting point</u>


Christianity is … […]
Christianity is not ____ with economics. The idea of E., as a {separated to depart.} of human life, _____ by its own laws s.c. economics laws, is a <u>recent</u> development and entirely un-Christian.
 
However, economic question are __ path of a group of social problems. explains the ____ th think up economics with Xty by the way of the social problems.
 
a) This is futiles effort for Christianity bear no reference to social problems as such. It is concerned with the relation of man to God as


{{Page |n°=86}} <u>English society</u>
== English society ==
{{Page |n°=86}} English <u></u>


[…]
[…]

Revision as of 20:43, 9 May 2021


Text in English to type

[68] Theory of fascist Transformation (cont)
[69] Theory of fascist Transformation (cont)

Notes of readings on Tillich?

[70] Tillich (13)
the _____ about the {dunie}
possibility {is/in} a human possibility

”Were an event only a foreign substance in History it come ______ be absorbed by history nor and it continent to be operative in history! 138
the „____ of time”:
_____________: ___ rise out of history
Spernaturalism: foreign injection into history 138

„Bank does not recognize the value of ____ ________ about ____”, of religion ______ ______…

[71] What is this human entity? Can it be thought of only is something without the divine without the capacity for receiving answers from the divine and for ______ ga_____ of the divine?” 139

Certainly _____ is not revelation (is a human possibility, while revelation is impossibility (divine possibility). Yet revelation ____ not be even a divine possibility -- revelation is indeed revelation to man - if it _____ not be received by means of {Yorus} of _____ as human phenomena” (140)

Theology is not anthropology (heads to _________ and ______)

[72] „Hebelier's is a fortress _______ of human action ravaged of sin and without ____ to the divine or to the demonic” His _____ leaching on point. Refuses to ________ theological ethics.

Tolley: It is an _______ of existence without reference to both divine & human _________.

We live in three dimensions:
1)
2) form ______ it
3) third dimension: divine mountain top
demonic abyss.

True is every day & secular…

„One who does not recognize that fact and who, mistaken, holding to the belief ___.

[73] two dimensional reality renounces the religions conflict against physical, social and spiritual demonic forces, in _____ journal of economics interests.

In this respect the battle on {theology} is _________ in ____ of guilty.” 144

Liberal theology, through its belief in progress, has been guilty as of obscuring the demonic.

{Barth}: _______ of human activities from both divine and demonic progress…

„Both deny the realism of dialectic, that is three-dimensional, thinking.” 145

Theory of the Facist Transformation (cont.)

[74] The influence of the working class a {nuisance} value.

Positive _____
a)
b)
c)
d) reforming capitalism of factory

more ______ a)
b)

[75] […]

… is Jesus Christus ein Rechtig___ und ein Wahrheit _____, kein Gesellschaft, kein {Sikengott}, kein Kirchen-, ____-, und K________gott! 67

[…] „Jesus ist Sieger!“

[…]

[76] […] Karl Marx war theological.

„Kleanthes” Dialog von 24 B____ eine philosophische-dialektische __________ __ Gottheit…“

His _____ ___ ____ theological _______ law, theology, etc.

Hegel {lapt} die Stände […].

[77] Marx on the „Corporative State”

There is a Criticism of Marx in the Corporative State which is of very real interest.

It was a _______. We are faced by a ____ view. Fascism […] to the stage at which Hegel ____ to fix them in the 1820s.

Capitalism was coming, now it is outgoing. But we do not overate to-day their phases. Capitalism was centuries old, and certainly … […]

Hegel gave an idealized version of the Prussian State of his time.

We do not say that {France} is nothing else but absolutism.

[78] Theory of fascist Transformation (cont)

{France}: International exchange ([…]) Germany (______)
England
Japan
Italy
Austria
Yougoslavia etc. Democracy ______

{A very […]

[…]

[79] Theory of fascist Transformation (cont)

Exact nature of crisis must be {assertained} working class ____ in its ______, principles, _______ both ___ […]; unemployment

[…]

a) left […]
b) […]

[80] à la Hegel + a modernisation of the Corporations and States of the Realm. But these are certainly, very close analyses.

It is perhaps worthwhile to re-translate Hegel difficult _____ ___ plain English in order to get at the meaning of ___'s command.

[81] ? __________ Gesellschaft = economic life
political sphere - economic sphere

1) Hegel refuses to accept the individual as the with of the political State.

He prefers the family and economic life the later as _________ corporations. | Hitlerism insists of family!

The State emerges out of the family and economic life […] of nature out of which the ____ of the State leaps (23)

[82] Theory of fascist Transformation (cont)

Two ______ of balance: […] a) political system must be sufficiently workable (extreme cases! […]

a) England …

b) Germany …

c) Italy: …

d) Austria …

e) Poland: … […]

[83] When Hegel in his curious phenomenology makes the family and the economic life are the two […]

First: What does Hegel say: family and economic life are stated to be the two ”____ into which the real … […]

What about the {individualized}

[84]Like ___, the man” The absence of servant class … […]

[85] Christianity an M economics

I In search of a starting point

Christianity is not ____ with economics. The idea of E., as a {separated to depart.} of human life, _____ by its own laws s.c. economics laws, is a recent development and entirely un-Christian.

However, economic question are __ path of a group of social problems. explains the ____ th think up economics with Xty by the way of the social problems.

a) This is futiles effort for Christianity bear no reference to social problems as such. It is concerned with the relation of man to God as

English society

[86] English

[…]

[87] For ______ interest society is restricted to that aspect of society in which it is a _______ of , a relationship of persons.

This implies […]

That is about the relationships of man to God.

… the relation of man to man

Ad 3: Jesus did not able to the law ___ meaning of religion […]

a relationship of persons.

[88] Theory of fascist Transformation (cont)

What is the market economy?

[…]

[89] Theory of fascist Transformation (cont)

[…]

[90] Theory of the Fascist Transformation (cont)

Something happening before our eyes
1) Depth and exclusion
2) Universality -
3) […]
4) […]
5) […]
6) […]
7) […]

[…]

[91] revealed to us in Jesus Christ. Only if economics bear any reference to this its achieve issue can we be concerned with it as Xtians.

II. When and in what _____ do social questions a bear reference to Xty?

[…]

[92] I What Xty is about the relationship of man to God

II. That this relationship is ________ with the relationship of mankind to God

III. That this relationship of mankind to God ______ on the relation of man _______.

Ad 1.

1d 2: […]

[93] Society as …

[94] […]

[95] […]

To such a society the Xtian says no! He leaves this ____ Jew left it the _____, […].

This was […]

The Gospel was apocalyptic. The disruption of society was […]. It was d________ as untenable. […] order of things was proclaimed.

[96] Xtian sociology

[97] b) The State of mankind - that's the one ____ing interest.

How do we get the knowledge … […]

[98] James […]

[99] Bryce: The American Commonwealth

542:
„Economic theory ___ not stop them, for practical when are proud of getting on without theory” 542

„The […]

[100] […]

[101] […]

[102] […]

[103] […]

[104] […]

[105] 16 {April} '35
Copec : Vol. N

Very good

[106] Adams (continued) Epic of thi____ 1931

p. 37 […]

[107]

[108] […]

5) Xtianity about wiped out: a) Russia
b) Germany

[109] …1935 possibilities as _____ to 1924:

[110] […] Yes, but they {withdrown} this trend with the help of the mother {Comity}; and […]

Polanyi:

[111] Jesus' apocalyptic attitude referred not _______ but to Jewish society. His premises justified by events (__ ____)

What is the essentially happening to the World?

[…] … problem of the social crisis by „deshumanizing” life radically. This is, of course, _____.

The World and the individual
_______ the Temporal
Sin - and Society

[112] This society destroyed leg X because it ___ not know the will of God.

The Church ____ […]

[113] 1.
2.
3.
4. The Church should be and not do.
prophecy! 5.
6. „Quality of life“ (John!) … […]
7.

[114] Adams (cont)

[…]

[115] […] … U.S.A. (Very ______ foul! […] 1924-1933 […]

[116] […]

[117] They […]

Negro slaves : up to 1698 …

[118] [119] [120] [121] [122] Charles of Beard […]

[123]

[124]

[125]

[126]

[127]

[128]

[129]

[130]

[131] Thorstein Veblen: The Theory of the Leisure Class (1899) New York Vanguard Press 1927

[132] […]

[133] Notes on Fascism

Organised Capitalism (from the …)

[134]

[135]

[136]

[137]

[138]

[139]

[140]

[141]

[142]

[143]

[144]

[145]

[146]

[147] […]

{More}: Personality: …
{Betrialism}
Jewish Question − Xristianity
Bergson: judeo-christian
————— ______: judeo-Protestant
Marx:
Rosenberg: Antisemitism explained

[148] G. Feder
[…] Positive Xristianity: __________
Negative Xristianity: Rosenberg {makes} Xristianity negative.

On mysticism: anti-individualism
[…]

Marx: […]

progressive revelation of the nature of man

[149] {Ponizhom}: biocentric theory of community

[153] Rosenberg

[154] Things to check:
Bergson:

[154] … on Spann's personal relationship

Document Informations

Reference:
Date: 1935
KPA: 07/08, 53-156