22/03: Difference between revisions

From Karl Polanyi
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page with "Anthropologie économique, préparation de The Livelihood of Man) Tentative de transcription de la p. 104 : [p.104] Ch. 1 Confusion of Economics + Market form Ch. 2 How did...")
 
 
(16 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
Anthropologie économique, préparation de The Livelihood of Man)
== KPI Description ==
Tentative de transcription de la p. 104 :
[p.104] Ch. 1  Confusion of Economics + Market form
Ch. 2 How did this afford the other disphnos ?
I. Economic theory: I’ll gave a phases to economic theory


Economic approach x (exchange)
{| class="wikitable"
The distribution of the material dilemma
| Title
Market + its laws
| Notes – Economic anthropology
A theory of price
|-
Limitations An equilibrium + a scarcity theory
| Author
Theories of cabes lacking
| Polanyi, Karl
|-
| Description
| File contains Karl Polanyi’s mostly hand-written notes on economic anthropology. Included in the file are also references to R. Thurnwald, Ernst Schonbauer, and others. The notes are in English.
|-
| URI
| [http://hdl.handle.net/10694/783 http://hdl.handle.net/10694/783]
|-
| Archive Date
| 2010-09-10
|}


M. Weber: Categories very effective but
== Content ==
Bowling : quotes œnived from current meanings
=== Notes ===
<div class="hand-written">
{{Page |n°=8}} […]<br />
(B) <u>The limits of ec. theory</u>


Catallactic triad trade xxxx absorbed by the market: constitution of monopolies of supply and for the use of xxxxxx  
(A) <u>The methodenstreit</u><br />
social sciences
<u>theoretical economics</u> event was Sch mother Hist. School
A theory [that] became the wrong theory to give a lead for the xxxxxx of the xx of the e. ver torie.
Menger limited it to "advanced, {natural} economies (monetized, ________ value scale.)
II. Economic history
 
Classical beginnings preceder. Ec. Theory. Still immense : (Boeche compare with Andreades (mirror of a century later)
(B) <u>Formal economies</u>:<br />
A faithful xxxx of L.MN fashions of the 1920’s.  
equilibrium<br />
Stages theories : Hildebrand, Plenge, Salin, Meichellkein: Spieth of Laune : marxism
Walras, Schumpeterian interdependence _____ economistic (_________ __ generation game theory (correct)
Nuscham theory: Bendiscen: Knapp. Mistle n inis. Petri Was. Oniggin.
 
(C) <u>Extension to socialist</u> (ie non-market economies: <u>Menger</u>.
Wieser, Böhm-Bawerk : <u>critical of cap.</u>
<u>Mises</u>: negative (critical)<br />
impossibility of socialism
 
Pol. Socialist Accountancy
 
(D) <u>Extension of theoreti. economies</u>
--- to monopoly, oligopoly to aggregates, to decision making
 
(E) Preindustrial non-market economies
 
<u>The economistic fallacy</u><br />
___ to Antiquity  (oikos controversy)
 
</div>
 
=== Notes for an interdisciplinary study involving anthropology and economic history ===
{{Page |n°=14}}
 
New York, Febr. 20th, 1953
 
=== ? ===
{{Page |n°=24}} […] Menger scarcity
 
=== (Complete Paradigm) ===
{{Page |n°=28}}
{|
| Anthropology:
| Primitive economies
|-
|rowspan="2"|Sociology:
| the institutionnalization of the economic process<br >
|-
| the _________________________________
|-
|rowspan="2"|History:
| ________________
|-
| economic "doctrines
|-
|rowspan="2"|Economic history:
| ________________
|-
| catallactic triad
|-
| History of law
|
|-
| Economic theory
|-
|rowspan="4"|Philosophy
| Aristotle's ____
|-
| N______________
|-
| ____________________
|-
| ________________
|}
 
=== [[Notes on Readings on Economic Anthropology]] ===
 
=== First list of Names ===
<div class="hand-written"> {{Page |n°=34}} Rosemary M_______ Arnold<br />
Walter Castle Neale<br />
Jim Blackman<br />
Peter Crawford<br />
Harry Pearson<br />
K.C. Yeh<br />
Soc: Terence Hopkins
 
=== Plan and Market in Early Society ===
{{Page |n°=47}}
 
=== New / old Testaments ===
{{Page |n°=51}} <u style="text-decoration-style: double;">New Testament</u>
 
(a) {Nature trait}<br />
(b) 30 pieces of silver an equivalence <u>reminiscence</u> <u style="text-decoration-style:double;">Old Testament</u>
(c) classical Greece: charge of gross ignorance
(d) Aristotle's terms
 
=== ??? ===
{{Page |n°=71}} Kafka:  1922<br />
<u>Thurnwald</u>
 
=== Plan of ''The Livelihood of Man''? ===
{{Question}}
<div class="hand-written">
{{Page |n°=104}} Ch. 1  Confusion of Economics + Market form<br />
<span style="margin-left:33px">Ch. 2 How did this afford the other disphnos ?</span>
 
<u>I. Economic theory</u>: I’ll gave a phases to economic theory<br />
<span style="margin-left:112px">Economic approach x (exchange)<br /></span>
<span style="margin-left:112px">The distribution of the material dilemma<br /></span>
<span style="margin-left:112px">Market + its laws<br /></span>
<span style="margin-left:112px">A theory of price<br /></span>
Limitations<span style="margin-left:45px"><u>An equilibrium + a scarcity theory</u></span><br />
<span style="margin-left:112px">Theories of cabes lacking</span>
 
M. Weber: Categories<br />
Bowling : quotes<span style="margin-left:20px">very effective but œnived from current meanings</span>
 
Catallactic triad<span style="margin-left:25px;">trade money<br /></span>
<span style="margin-left:110px">absorbed by the market: constitution of monopolies of supply and for the use of xxxxxx social sciences</span>
 
A theory [that] became the wrong theory to give a lead for the xxxxxx of the xx of the e. ver torie.<br />
 
<u>II. Economic history</u><br />
Classical beginnings preceder. Ec. Theory. Still immense : (Boeche compare with Andreades (mirror of a century later)<br />
A faithful xxxx of L.MN fashions of the 1920’s.<br />
Stages theories : <u>Hildebrand</u>, <u>Plenge</u>, Salin, Meichellkein: Spieth of Laune : marxism<br />
Nuscham theory: Bendiscen: Knapp. Mistle n inis. Petri Was. Oniggin.<br />
Market theory: Rostovtzeff.
Market theory: Rostovtzeff.


[105]
{{Page |n°=105}}
1940 The amateur pencil philosophers symphony in Hamster of the host and contributy in very signal desidary to the stream<br />
[[File:KPA 22-03, 105.jpg|thumb|right|480px]]
Drucker, Polanyis<br />
<u>1940</u> The {amateur} social philosophers {strongpling} in {Hamster} of the host and {contributing} in very {siffvent} {desidary} to the stream<br />
Popper<br />
<span style="margin-left:25px;">Drucker,<br /></span>
Bosherman<br />
<span style="margin-left:25px;">{Polanyis}<br /></span>
Hoestler<br />
<span style="margin-left:25px;">Popper<br /></span>
Hayek<br />
<span style="margin-left:25px;">{Bosherman}<br /></span>
Srilard<br />
<span style="margin-left:25px;">Koestler<br /></span>
<span style="margin-left:25px;">Hayek<br /></span>
<span style="margin-left:25px;">Szilard</span>
 
{{Page |n°=106}} Ch. 2 (continued)<br />
economic history (continued) <br />
οικος controversy: Rodbertus {tadled}  the taxation system of Rome in a reality way as that of <u>non-market</u> economy.
 
[…] … {Bresher} - Menger. The latter's <u>posthumous {history/victory}</u> in M. Weber. However, Weber history {developed} the anthropology line / Menger in {affecting tool} ____ the savage _____ of antiquity.
 
<u>Weber</u> deliberately refused to separate the subst. economy from formal i.e. market theory.
 
[…]
 
{{Page |n°=111}}<br />
Ch. 1<span style="margin-left:25px;">Fake investigation of the economy …</span><br />
Ch. 2<span style="margin-left:25px;">How did this affect …</span>
 
<u>I. Economic theory</u>
Polanyi rewrites plan for chapter II and quotes the catallactics.
 
Weber<br />
<u>catallactic triad</u>
 
</div>
 
=== Notes on reading Karl's Notes of Place Occupied by Economies in Societies ===
{{Page |n°=112}} - {{Page |n°=117}}
 
=== Menu ===
{{Page |n°=118}}
27 March 1953
 
=== Second list of names ===
<div class="hand-written">
Daniel Fusfeld written Ap 15, 1953<br />
Rosemary Arnold<br />
Charles Silbermann
?<br />
Horst
Joseph ?<br />
Conrad M. Arensberg<br />
William {Victory}<br />
?<br />
R.K. Merton<br />
?<br />
J.H.B. Randalff<br />
?<br />
Harry W. Pearson<br />
K?<br />
Margaret Mead (___ KP)<br />
Frank Tannenbaum  (___ KP)<br />
 


(Le développement du chapitre II continue sur la p. 106)
</div>
P. 111 : Polanyi réécrit le plan du chapitre II et cite la catallactics.

Latest revision as of 16:37, 6 May 2019

KPI Description

Title Notes – Economic anthropology
Author Polanyi, Karl
Description File contains Karl Polanyi’s mostly hand-written notes on economic anthropology. Included in the file are also references to R. Thurnwald, Ernst Schonbauer, and others. The notes are in English.
URI http://hdl.handle.net/10694/783
Archive Date 2010-09-10

Content

Notes

[8] […]
(B) The limits of ec. theory

(A) The methodenstreit
theoretical economics event was Sch mother Hist. School Menger limited it to "advanced, {natural} economies (monetized, ________ value scale.)

(B) Formal economies:
equilibrium
Walras, Schumpeterian interdependence _____ economistic (_________ __ generation game theory (correct)

(C) Extension to socialist (ie non-market economies: Menger. Wieser, Böhm-Bawerk : critical of cap. Mises: negative (critical)
impossibility of socialism

Pol. Socialist Accountancy

(D) Extension of theoreti. economies --- to monopoly, oligopoly to aggregates, to decision making

(E) Preindustrial non-market economies

The economistic fallacy
___ to Antiquity (oikos controversy)

Notes for an interdisciplinary study involving anthropology and economic history

[14]

New York, Febr. 20th, 1953

?

[24] […] Menger scarcity

(Complete Paradigm)

[28]

Anthropology: Primitive economies
Sociology: the institutionnalization of the economic process
the _________________________________
History: ________________
economic "doctrines
Economic history: ________________
catallactic triad
History of law
Economic theory
Philosophy Aristotle's ____
N______________
____________________
________________

Notes on Readings on Economic Anthropology

First list of Names

[34] Rosemary M_______ Arnold

Walter Castle Neale
Jim Blackman
Peter Crawford
Harry Pearson
K.C. Yeh
Soc: Terence Hopkins

Plan and Market in Early Society

[47]

New / old Testaments

[51] New Testament

(a) {Nature trait}
(b) 30 pieces of silver an equivalence reminiscence Old Testament (c) classical Greece: charge of gross ignorance (d) Aristotle's terms

???

[71] Kafka: 1922
Thurnwald

Plan of The Livelihood of Man?

This page contains question(s)
that we should discuss
in the Talk Page!

[104] Ch. 1 Confusion of Economics + Market form
Ch. 2 How did this afford the other disphnos ?

I. Economic theory: I’ll gave a phases to economic theory
Economic approach x (exchange)
 The distribution of the material dilemma
 Market + its laws
 A theory of price
 LimitationsAn equilibrium + a scarcity theory
Theories of cabes lacking

M. Weber: Categories
Bowling : quotesvery effective but œnived from current meanings

Catallactic triadtrade money
 absorbed by the market: constitution of monopolies of supply and for the use of xxxxxx social sciences

A theory [that] became the wrong theory to give a lead for the xxxxxx of the xx of the e. ver torie.

II. Economic history
Classical beginnings preceder. Ec. Theory. Still immense : (Boeche compare with Andreades (mirror of a century later)
A faithful xxxx of L.MN fashions of the 1920’s.
Stages theories : Hildebrand, Plenge, Salin, Meichellkein: Spieth of Laune : marxism
Nuscham theory: Bendiscen: Knapp. Mistle n inis. Petri Was. Oniggin.
Market theory: Rostovtzeff.

[105]

1940 The {amateur} social philosophers {strongpling} in {Hamster} of the host and {contributing} in very {siffvent} {desidary} to the stream
Drucker,
 {Polanyis}
 Popper
 {Bosherman}
 Koestler
 Hayek
 Szilard

[106] Ch. 2 (continued)
economic history (continued)
οικος controversy: Rodbertus {tadled} the taxation system of Rome in a reality way as that of non-market economy.

[…] … {Bresher} - Menger. The latter's posthumous {history/victory} in M. Weber. However, Weber history {developed} the anthropology line / Menger in {affecting tool} ____ the savage _____ of antiquity.

Weber deliberately refused to separate the subst. economy from formal i.e. market theory.

[…]

[111]
Ch. 1Fake investigation of the economy …
Ch. 2How did this affect …

I. Economic theory Polanyi rewrites plan for chapter II and quotes the catallactics.

Weber
catallactic triad

Notes on reading Karl's Notes of Place Occupied by Economies in Societies

[112] - [117]

Menu

[118] 27 March 1953

Second list of names

Daniel Fusfeld written Ap 15, 1953
Rosemary Arnold
Charles Silbermann ?
Horst Joseph ?
Conrad M. Arensberg
William {Victory}
?
R.K. Merton
?
J.H.B. Randalff
?
Harry W. Pearson
K?
Margaret Mead (___ KP)
Frank Tannenbaum (___ KP)


Retrieved from "http://karl.polanyi.fr/wiki/index.php?title=22/03&oldid=15837"