Notebook XIII - Revision history

Santiago Pinault: /* ? (Dec 28 - Jan 2) */

2019-11-26T00:33:26Z

? (Dec 28 - Jan 2)

← Older revision		Revision as of 01:33, 26 November 2019
Line 468:		Line 468:

	1848 <u>Communist Manifesto</u>		1848 <u>Communist Manifesto</u>
			Landhsut and Meyer, Early Marx, carrie title “Historical Materialism”?

	~~[…]~~		Marx and Engels {continually} intolerant to basis of their movement - _____ theological atmosphere which ____ them realistic importance of unity (or} clarity.
	9/10 of Marx is theol. discussion ~~K______ apprent~~ - even Proudhon who looked upon atheism as a religious position - he is wavered between positive theology ({seducing/reducing} nature) or negative a (<u>{induc.}</u> nature.) Blake a similar Luciferian position -- cf. Lawrence, Macmurray Etc. Stood for “marriage of Heaven? ~~& {Selt}”~~ - Reason & Emotion.<br />
			9/10 of Marx is theol. discussion to answer opponents - even Proudhon who looked upon atheism as a religious position - he is wavered between positive theology ({seducing/reducing} nature) or negative a (<u>{induc.}</u> nature.) Blake a similar Luciferian position -- cf. Lawrence, Macmurray Etc. Stood for “marriage of Heaven? or Hell - Reason & Emotion.<br />
	Proudhon's anarchism fused with anarchist atheism.		Proudhon's anarchism fused with anarchist atheism.

Line 477:		Line 479:
	{\|		{\|
	\| I. Thesis.		\| I. Thesis.
	\| Marx objects __ activity-reduct. w <u>~~_____~~</u> - Feuerbach only conceives of {man so}.		\| Marx objects __ activity-reduct. w <u>thinking</u> - Feuerbach only conceives of {man so}.
	\|-		\|-
	\| II. Thesis.		\| II. Thesis.

Santiago Pinault at 19:58, 4 September 2019

2019-09-04T19:58:51Z

Show changes

Santiago Pinault at 07:57, 4 September 2019

2019-09-04T07:57:15Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 08:57, 4 September 2019
Line 1:		Line 1:
	~~{{English to type}}~~		[[File:KPA 07-03, 1.jpg\|500px\|thumb\|right]]

	__TOC__		__TOC__
	~~[[File:KPA 07-03, 1.jpg\|500px\|thumb\|right]]~~
	<div class="hand-written">		<div class="hand-written">

	No 1945		No 1945

Line 22:		Line 21:
	(b) ______ world revolution: for reactionary reasons.		(b) ______ world revolution: for reactionary reasons.

			(a) is a crit. of judgment or theory
			(b) " " " of a person - human judgment

			__ 1924 Stat san to politic no bourgeoisie possible but to achieve ___ in Russia world revol. necessary and now Stalin says the society <u>is</u> achieved.

			Considered NEP an illustration of concession W capitalism - ie necessary retreat. But Trotsky himself advises retreat (eg partitions of Russia)

			“Government of dictatorship of proletariat” {hers} {bein} strengthened. <u>But in that case state stands at once begin W die away</u>.

			But have not new conditions ____, making change of policy necessary? But Trot. says - they need not, if clean, he side

			{{English to type}}
	{{Page \|n°=6}} <u>Neo Constitution</u> …		{{Page \|n°=6}} <u>Neo Constitution</u> …
	[…]		[…]
Line 752:		Line 762:
	{{Page \|n°=89}} depend on which are the <u>people</u> with whom we make contact.		{{Page \|n°=89}} depend on which are the <u>people</u> with whom we make contact.

	{{Page \|n°=90}} [[#mw-page-base\|↑]]		{{Page \|n°=90}}</div> [[#mw-page-base\|↑]]

	== Missing pages ==		== (Missing pages) ==
	Pages 90-98 in the ~~archive (81-86 in the notebook)~~ are missing. {{Question}}		Pages 90-98 of the Notebook are missing, at least on the pdf archive. {{Question}}

	== ~~Saving, Remnant~~ ==		<div class="hand-written">
	{{Page \|n°=91}} ~~<u>Saving, Remnant</u><br />~~		== “Saving Remnant” ==
	(Feb. 4, 1938)		{{Page \|n°=91}} (Feb. 4, 1938)

	There is a positive dynamic in history of which the dialectic a describes the way the positive overcomes the negative at its worst - thronef that may include complete obliteration in failure of disaster.		There is a positive dynamic in history of which the dialectic a describes the way the positive overcomes the negative at its worst - thronef that may include complete obliteration in failure of disaster.
Line 776:		Line 786:
	Alone period … like … struggle … universal human society: brotherhood is religion _____ed Fr. Revolution […]		Alone period … like … struggle … universal human society: brotherhood is religion _____ed Fr. Revolution […]

	{\|		{\|style="max-width:900px;"
	\| 1793		\| 1793
	\| Interaction of attitude to politics of the other things. Before Fr. Revol. only <u>Songs of Innocence</u> a description of King. of Heaven (childhood). Five pos later (after Rev:) <u>Songs of experience</u>? Two contrary states of human evol: the latter - after - the Fall.<br />Fr. Rev. made his views on art, psychology, sex etc. revolutionary. Blake already religious against injustice in Songs of experience? _____ Church & Co because used as excuse for exploitation . With sex morality. Before songs of experience is a poem <u>on</u> Fr. Revol. (only one book written & not published. Belonging of an epic after French Revolution. Unique as revolution poem because it gives reaction (the Devil) more than his one, to show seriousness of the conflict. Hoped the privileged classes		\| Interaction of attitude to politics of the other things. Before Fr. Revol. only <u>Songs of Innocence</u> a description of King. of Heaven (childhood). Five pos later (after Rev:) <u>Songs of experience</u>? Two contrary states of human evol: the latter - after - the Fall.<br />Fr. Rev. made his views on art, psychology, sex etc. revolutionary. Blake already religious against injustice in Songs of experience? _____ Church & Co because used as excuse for exploitation . With sex morality. Before songs of experience is a poem <u>on</u> Fr. Revol. (only one book written & not published. Belonging of an epic after French Revolution. Unique as revolution poem because it gives reaction (the Devil) more than his one, to show seriousness of the conflict. Hoped the privileged classes

Santiago Pinault: /* Saving, Remnant */

2019-09-03T21:06:32Z

Saving, Remnant

← Older revision		Revision as of 22:06, 3 September 2019
Line 765:		Line 765:
	It is the function of a saving remnant carry over a consciousness of the meaning and significance of a life all institutional embodiments of which may have perished or even beat to the minds conscious ____ of the vast majority of human beings. This function cannot be fulfilled by an individual but only by a community constituted by this consciousness.		It is the function of a saving remnant carry over a consciousness of the meaning and significance of a life all institutional embodiments of which may have perished or even beat to the minds conscious ____ of the vast majority of human beings. This function cannot be fulfilled by an individual but only by a community constituted by this consciousness.

	The possibility of human society surviving sudden transformations can scarcely be {deplained} without reference to the special function of such committees. This function is possible {{Page \|n°=92}} the emerging society with that vital understanding of life which will enable it to {pessist}. The community itself having lived by it in a _______ mechanical society - (a saving remnant) the thus believe in such “saving remnants”, and their function. an ultimate assurance even in face of the possibility of catastrophe or failure.		The possibility of human society surviving sudden transformations can scarcely be {deplained} without reference to the special function of such committees. This function is possible {{Page \|n°=92}} the emerging society with that vital understanding of life which will enable it to {pessist}. The community itself having lived by it in a _______ mechanical society - (a saving remnant) the thus believe in such “saving remnants”, and their function. An ultimate assurance even in face of the possibility of catastrophe or failure.

	He reject the temptations which are implicit in this fact, namely the {wolcany} of catastrophe as the opportunity for individual salvation. The saving of ones life by taking mystically upon oneself the decision w {lose} it.		He reject the temptations which are implicit in this fact, namely the {wolcany} of catastrophe as the opportunity for individual salvation. The saving of ones life by taking mystically upon oneself the decision w {lose} it.
Line 778:		Line 778:
	{\|		{\|
	\| 1793		\| 1793
	\| Interaction of attitude to politics of the other things. Before Fr. Revol. only <u>Songs of Innocence</u> a description of King. of Heaven (childhood). Five pos later (after Rev:) <u>Songs of experience</u>? Two contrary states of human evol: the latter - after - the Fall.<br />Fr. Rev. made his ~~news~~ on art, psychology, sex etc. revolutionary. Blake already religious against injustice in Songs of experience? _____ Church & Co because used as excuse for exploitation . With sex morality. Before songs of experience is a poem <u>on</u> Fr. Revol. (only one book written & not published. Belonging of an epic after French Revolution. Unique as revolution poem because it gives reaction (the Devil) more than his one, to show seriousness of the conflict. Hoped the privileged classes		\| Interaction of attitude to politics of the other things. Before Fr. Revol. only <u>Songs of Innocence</u> a description of King. of Heaven (childhood). Five pos later (after Rev:) <u>Songs of experience</u>? Two contrary states of human evol: the latter - after - the Fall.<br />Fr. Rev. made his views on art, psychology, sex etc. revolutionary. Blake already religious against injustice in Songs of experience? _____ Church & Co because used as excuse for exploitation . With sex morality. Before songs of experience is a poem <u>on</u> Fr. Revol. (only one book written & not published. Belonging of an epic after French Revolution. Unique as revolution poem because it gives reaction (the Devil) more than his one, to show seriousness of the conflict. Hoped the privileged classes
	\|-		\|-
	\| 1790		\| 1790
	\| I would give up then privileges. but the revolution ____ of <u>Marriage of ~~Heavan~~ & ~~hell~~</u> “Without contraries is no progression” - Good is the passive, objective reason. Evil is {{Page \|n°=95}} energy or emotion.		\| I would give up then privileges. but the revolution ____ of <u>Marriage of Heaven & Hell</u> “Without contraries is no progression” - Good is the passive, objective reason. Evil is {{Page \|n°=95}} energy or emotion.<ref>Original text: “Without Contraries is no progression. Attraction and Repulsion, Reason and Energy, Love and Hate are necessary to Human existence. From these contraries spring what the religious call Good & Evil. Good is the passive that obeys Reason. Evil is the active springing from Energy. Good is Heaven. Evil is Hell.”</ref>
			\|}
			(1) Man has nobody from his soul (instead of vice versa)<br />
			(2) Energy is only life _is from the body<br />
			(3) Reason is the outcome circonference of energy.

	(~~1)<br />~~		Energy - the Devil - {Millon} of the devils party without knowing it. (Luciferian)
	(2)~~<br />~~
	~~(3) Reason is the outcome …~~

			Read Proverb of Hell.<br />
	Read “America”		Read “America”

			For Blake no waterlight compartiments - his art supersession of art, as his poem other politics. Described capitalism, alienation in Marx's terms. “Self-alienation”

	~~For blake no waterlight compartement~~ [[#mw-page-base\|↑]]		His views on religion change a lot. Developped stress on conflict but reason & emotion - in Jerusalem {Milton} describe religion as brotherhood. But in prefaces a somewhat different description. Most profound {o}bjcation w religion of his <u>time</u> was its identification w. morality - which would make Socrates saviour. Morality is <u>only</u> forgiveness. Forgiveness of Man by Joseph was of the Essential nature of the incarnation. “Take away the remembrence of <u>sin</u>”. Cf. Macmurray in Creative Society.

			“One for another to first off by forgiveness every Sin” (Mutuality of forgiveness) [[#mw-page-base\|↑]]
	</div>		</div>

Santiago Pinault: /* Saving, Remnant */

2019-09-03T20:07:15Z

Saving, Remnant

← Older revision		Revision as of 21:07, 3 September 2019
Line 761:		Line 761:
	(Feb. 4, 1938)		(Feb. 4, 1938)

	There is a positive dynamic in history of which the dialectic a describes the way the positive overcomes the negative at its worst -		There is a positive dynamic in history of which the dialectic a describes the way the positive overcomes the negative at its worst - thronef that may include complete obliteration in failure of disaster.

			It is the function of a saving remnant carry over a consciousness of the meaning and significance of a life all institutional embodiments of which may have perished or even beat to the minds conscious ____ of the vast majority of human beings. This function cannot be fulfilled by an individual but only by a community constituted by this consciousness.

	{{Page \|n°=92}} the emerging society with that vital understanding of life which will enable …		The possibility of human society surviving sudden transformations can scarcely be {deplained} without reference to the special function of such committees. This function is possible {{Page \|n°=92}} the emerging society with that vital understanding of life which will enable it to {pessist}. The community itself having lived by it in a _______ mechanical society - (a saving remnant) the thus believe in such “saving remnants”, and their function. an ultimate assurance even in face of the possibility of catastrophe or failure.

			He reject the temptations which are implicit in this fact, namely the {wolcany} of catastrophe as the opportunity for individual salvation. The saving of ones life by taking mystically upon oneself the decision w {lose} it.

	{{Page \|n°=93}} Statement on <u>Commitment</u> (feb 4-5.)		{{Page \|n°=93}} Statement on <u>Commitment</u> (feb 4-5.)
Line 771:		Line 774:

	{{Page \|n°=94}} <u>Kenneth Muir {Blake}</u>		{{Page \|n°=94}} <u>Kenneth Muir {Blake}</u>
	[…]		Alone period … like … struggle … universal human society: brotherhood is religion _____ed Fr. Revolution […]

	~~1793~~


	~~1790~~

	~~[…]~~ <u>Marriage of ~~Heaven or Hell~~</u> ~~“without~~ contraries in no progression” - Good is the passive, objective reason. Evil is {{Page \|n°=95}} ~~____~~ or emotion.		{\|
			\| 1793
			\| Interaction of attitude to politics of the other things. Before Fr. Revol. only <u>Songs of Innocence</u> a description of King. of Heaven (childhood). Five pos later (after Rev:) <u>Songs of experience</u>? Two contrary states of human evol: the latter - after - the Fall.<br />Fr. Rev. made his news on art, psychology, sex etc. revolutionary. Blake already religious against injustice in Songs of experience? _____ Church & Co because used as excuse for exploitation . With sex morality. Before songs of experience is a poem <u>on</u> Fr. Revol. (only one book written & not published. Belonging of an epic after French Revolution. Unique as revolution poem because it gives reaction (the Devil) more than his one, to show seriousness of the conflict. Hoped the privileged classes
			\|-
			\| 1790
			\| I would give up then privileges. but the revolution ____ of <u>Marriage of Heavan & hell</u> “Without contraries is no progression” - Good is the passive, objective reason. Evil is {{Page \|n°=95}} energy or emotion.

	(1)<br />		(1)<br />
Line 788:		Line 791:

	For blake no waterlight compartement [[#mw-page-base\|↑]]		For blake no waterlight compartement [[#mw-page-base\|↑]]
	</div>		</div>

	== Polanyi's Notes ==		== Polanyi's Notes ==

Santiago Pinault: /* ? (Dec 28 - Jan 2) */

2019-09-03T01:43:39Z

? (Dec 28 - Jan 2)

← Older revision		Revision as of 02:43, 3 September 2019
Line 404:		Line 404:
	{{Page \|n°=35}} {{Page \|n°=36}}		{{Page \|n°=35}} {{Page \|n°=36}}

	{{Page \|n°=37}} ~~Marx… […]~~ of <u>human ~~relation~~</u> are self-~~alienation~~ & objectivation synonymous?		{{Page \|n°=37}} Mx somewhat Interest & Profit are inherent in Capitalism (The State = <u>objectiv</u>, so theory of state dying) dy. of what? ---- ans. of <u>human relations</u> are self-alien & objectivation synonymous? Not in com. society. Not always ∴ synonymous (cf. anarchist).

	~~not in com. society. Not always ∴ synonymous (cf. anarchist)~~.		Dialectic as General Method.

	~~Dialectic as General Method~~.		Is Dia. Materialism to say Marxism Dialectics. Accepted {Trotsky} - Russian Engels Anti-Dühring interpretation also socialism: 1. Type of society 2. Properly {dyalein} 3. Ideology (of des c. {wortez})<br />
			(This leads to theory of class consciousness & {forelet} Revolution.)

			2 is dependent on 1.

			Start P_ of Marx was effort to understand his own world in simple terms; after that he was concerned with {Wor}-class revolut. (in Germany) (The socialist solution was not to be seen in Mx in 1837 -- but it was there in 1841.)

	<u>Early Works Marx</u>		<u>Early Works Marx</u><br />
	~~[…]~~		His ____ was liberal non-religious. This he {begantz} accepting. Vet passionate anti-Semitism & anti-Xty (like Hitler only for opposite motives.) He made Jewry responsible for all the bad in Xty, while Hitler makes it responsible for all the good.)

	{{Page \|n°=38}} <u>Early Works of Karl Marx</u><br />		{{Page \|n°=38}} <u>Early Works of Karl Marx</u><br />
	(In Landshut & Mayer in German)		(In Landshut & Mayer in German)<br />

	1837 Marx letter to his father<br />		1837 Marx letter to his father<br />
	1840 Doctor's thesis<br />		1840 Doctor's thesis<br />
Line 424:		Line 426:


	___ {unity} of <u>Critique of Hegel's Philo of State</u> ~~Marx… […]~~		___ {unity} of <u>Critique of Hegel's Philo of State</u> Marx __ ______ & actual succeeded in turning Hegel's method <u>upside down</u>. In Hegel “Critique of Hegel's Philosophy of the State”. Mars deals with Fascism under the term “corporations” & “burgerliche Gesellschaft” (mistranslated so fou. Karli suggests {merely/words} “industrial life”.)

			<u>Articles & Papers</u> - ____ Rheinische

	1842 Zeitung […]		1842 Zeitung […]
Line 432:		Line 436:
	1844 <u>National Ökonomie</u> […]		1844 <u>National Ökonomie</u> […]

	{{Page \|n°=39}}		{{Page \|n°=39}} 1844-5 <u>Heilige Familie</u> - anti-Bauer vs. Bauers affects of Su's nor

	1845 […]		1845-6 <u>Deutsche Ideologie</u> a collection of works, […]

	1845 […]		1845 <u>Leipziger Konzil</u> (a German socialist group) Not of gt importance.<br />
			<u>Heilige Max</u> (Stirner) […]

	{{Page \|n°=40}}		{{Page \|n°=40}} 1847 <u>Poverty of Phil.</u> (Anti-Proudhon)
	1847 <u>Poverty of Phil.</u> (Anti-Proudhon)

	1848 <u>Communist Manifesto</u>		1848 <u>Communist Manifesto</u>

			[…]
			9/10 of Marx is theol. discussion K______ apprent - even Proudhon who looked upon atheism as a religious position - he is wavered between positive theology ({seducing/reducing} nature) or negative a (<u>{induc.}</u> nature.) Blake a similar Luciferian position -- cf. Lawrence, Macmurray Etc. Stood for “marriage of Heaven? & {Selt}” - Reason & Emotion.<br />
			Proudhon's anarchism fused with anarchist atheism.

	{{Page \|n°=41}} {{Page \|n°=42}} {{Page \|n°=43}}		(See for ______ Handbook of Marxism “Deutsche Ideologie?)
			{{Page \|n°=41}}
			{\|
			\| I. Thesis.
			\| Marx objects __ activity-reduct. w <u>_____</u> - Feuerbach only conceives of {man so}.
			\|-
			\| II. Thesis.
			\|
			\|-
			\| III. Thesis.
			\|
			\|-
			\| IV. Thesis.
			\|
			\|-
			\| V. Thesis.
			\|
			\|-
			\| VI. Thesis.
			\|
			\|-
			\| VII. Thesis.
			\|
			\|-
			\| {{Page \|n°=42}} VIII. Thesis.
			\|
			\|-
			\| IX. Thesis.
			\|
			\|-
			\| X. Thesis.
			\| "civil” society = industrial life (Ger: “bugerliche Gesellschaft {{Page \|n°=43}} ie […]
			\|-
			\| XI. Thesis.
			\| Marx accepted fact that in <u>philosophy</u> he could add nothing to Hegel
			\|}

	{{Page \|n°=44}} Dec 30th. Morning		{{Page \|n°=44}} Dec 30th. Morning
Line 458:		Line 500:
	{{Page \|n°=47}} […]		{{Page \|n°=47}} […]

	(Here he ~~begin~~ to reject Hegel, but not reached historical materialism)		(Here he began to reject Hegel, but not reached historical materialism)

	[…]		[…]

Santiago Pinault at 05:26, 1 September 2019

2019-09-01T05:26:09Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 06:26, 1 September 2019
Line 271:		Line 271:
	A serial revolution in Jewish society <u>was a religious</u> revolution for the Jews - it was a <u>theocracy</u>.		A serial revolution in Jewish society <u>was a religious</u> revolution for the Jews - it was a <u>theocracy</u>.

	Did Jesus suddenly in the trial, realize that he had {restored/relooked} something <ref> i.e. that Pilate would come out - <u>for him</u>, even ~~thing~~ him to power.</ref> ~~− i.e.that Pilate _____ come out - <u>for</u> him, even bring him to power~~ − that he {covered} come to power, + on the side of the Romans − perhaps even become Roman Emperor! Only this could stop from going on to power.		Did Jesus suddenly in the trial, realize that he had {restored/relooked} something <ref group="p"> i.e. that Pilate would come out - <u>for him</u>, even bring him to power.</ref> − that he {covered} come to power, + on the side of the Romans − perhaps even become Roman Emperor! Only this could stop from going on to power.

	Did death was the way to ____ him […] clarification it was instituting.		Did death was the way to ____ him […] clarification it was instituting.
Line 747:		Line 747:
	For blake no waterlight compartement [[#mw-page-base\|↑]]		For blake no waterlight compartement [[#mw-page-base\|↑]]
	</div>		</div>

			== Polanyi's Notes ==

			<references group="p" />

	== Editor's Notes ==		== Editor's Notes ==

Santiago Pinault at 05:22, 1 September 2019

2019-09-01T05:22:47Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 06:22, 1 September 2019
Line 331:		Line 331:
	Macmurray in Xty Soc. Revolution<br />		Macmurray in Xty Soc. Revolution<br />
	Dialectical Materialism		Dialectical Materialism

			[[#mw-page-base\|↑]]

	== ? (Dec 28 - Jan 2) ==		== ? (Dec 28 - Jan 2) ==
Line 580:		Line 582:
	Why had Jesus to die identified with the Jews? Of throne wouldn't understand the meaning of a faith who had it, then <u>who should?</u> He <u>must</u> get ______ of the Jews somehow because this was the people who <u>had</u> it - this limit of him freedom, than ___ accepts the limit - it was to be ____________ <u>self-realization of their own ___ by the Jews.</u>)		Why had Jesus to die identified with the Jews? Of throne wouldn't understand the meaning of a faith who had it, then <u>who should?</u> He <u>must</u> get ______ of the Jews somehow because this was the people who <u>had</u> it - this limit of him freedom, than ___ accepts the limit - it was to be ____________ <u>self-realization of their own ___ by the Jews.</u>)

	Cf. Jewry {thers}		Cf. Jewry {thers} [[#mw-page-base\|↑]]

	== History & Class consciousness - Lukács, 1923 ==		== History & Class consciousness - Lukács, 1923 ==
Line 708:		Line 710:
	{{Page \|n°=89}} depend on which are the <u>people</u> with whom we make contact.		{{Page \|n°=89}} depend on which are the <u>people</u> with whom we make contact.

	{{Page \|n°=90}}		{{Page \|n°=90}} [[#mw-page-base\|↑]]

	== Missing pages ==		== Missing pages ==
Line 743:		Line 745:


	For blake no waterlight compartement		For blake no waterlight compartement [[#mw-page-base\|↑]]
	</div>		</div>

	== Editor's Notes ==		== Editor's Notes ==

Santiago Pinault at 18:00, 31 August 2019

2019-08-31T18:00:39Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 19:00, 31 August 2019
Line 17:		Line 17:
	N 12		N 12

	{{Page \|n°=5}} <u>Content of ~~____ty {~~crit.}</u>		{{Page \|n°=5}} <u>Content of Philosophy crit.</u>
	1) {Crit.} of Com. international ~~∴ USSR ∴ Stalin~~ withdraw from world Revolution.<br />		1) Crit. of Com. international ∴USSR ∴Stalin withdraw from world Revolution.<br />
	(a)<br />		(a)They say “economically is possible”<br />
	(b)		(b) ______ world revolution: for reactionary reasons.


	{{Page \|n°=5}} […] <u>speech in New York</u> - forms of soc. property		{{Page \|n°=6}} <u>Neo Constitution</u> …
			[…]

			<u>speech in New York</u> - forms of soc. property

			{{Page \|n°=7}} […]
			<u>K. Ingram</u> would world revolution have {obvated} a bureaucracy?

	{{Page \|n°=8}} […]		<u>Mac</u> […]

			<u>Karli</u> Trotsky says “bureaucracy is inevitable result of mistaken effort to produce socialism in Russia, in a non-capitalist country, it cannot function - except in a bureaucracy. Because scarcity of goods make compulsory … […]

			{{Page \|n°=8}} Diffic. of discussion is that neither Trot. pos. nor communist pos. is … […]

	Unless Trotsky really <u>is</u> trying … Stalin {rco}, then there w__ to us position discussing him.		Unless Trotsky really <u>is</u> trying … Stalin {rco}, then there w__ to us position discussing him.
Line 33:		Line 43:
	But was all _____ carried ___ly Trotsky {its}.		But was all _____ carried ___ly Trotsky {its}.

	If ~~Trotstky~~ came in in Russia, what is there programme? - Like in 1917 - Lenin ∴ Trotsky want say the question is an abstraction. Such a change would actually. __tail wars about Russia on Russia ∴ revolution: ___ally out all _____ would say that in the meantime he would fulfil a “retreat” policy – _______ collectives, {stasty} peasant ________ __ (Possibilist régime.)		If Trotsky came in in Russia, what is there programme? - Like in 1917 - Lenin ∴ Trotsky want say the question is an abstraction. Such a change would actually. __tail wars about Russia on Russia ∴ revolution: ___ally out all _____ would say that in the meantime he would fulfil a “retreat” policy – _______ collectives, {stasty} peasant ________ __ (Possibilist régime.)

	How is this consistent with POUM line which is ie Gvt with socialist _____? A soviet regime in Barcelona would mean war in Europe - They ____ use Frank ______.		How is this consistent with POUM line which is ie Gvt with socialist _____? A soviet regime in Barcelona would mean war in Europe - They ____ use Frank ______.
Line 207:		Line 217:
	On position (theological) was Marx's man interest. Just as John Mac. sp. (understand w. K. class restructure of society)		On position (theological) was Marx's man interest. Just as John Mac. sp. (understand w. K. class restructure of society)

	~~Ruch~~. Implicits in Jewish Church of Revol: what about Jesus regarding arrest & trial?		Ruth.<ref>Must be Rutherford.</ref> Implicits in Jewish Church of Revol: what about Jesus regarding arrest & trial?

	Jesus = relig. refers community<br /> […]		Jesus = relig. refers community<br /> […]
Line 216:		Line 226:

	{{Page \|n°=23}} Jesus = prophete s priest<br />		{{Page \|n°=23}} Jesus = prophete s priest<br />
	men must ask & {late} ~~responsability~~ instead of “______ing __”. It is up to man; it is man who must do the {forgering}: man {in/is} turning from___ negate his own natures ∴ he has to turn the converted.		men must ask & {late} responsibility instead of “______ing __”. It is up to man; it is man who must do the {forgering}: man {in/is} turning from___ negate his own natures ∴ he has to turn the converted.

	The point asked, was that Jesus that of Theocracy.		The point asked, was that Jesus that of Theocracy.
Line 224:		Line 234:
	authoritative, or avoided Church.		authoritative, or avoided Church.

	Jesus began in Synagogue. […]		Jesus began in Synagogue. Not ___ clue his teaching but on… […]<br />
			In Sermon on Mt he quest to ___ of Jewish law.<br />
			It was construct. way he dealt with criticism.

	In J. position we see a free person naturally acting ____ -- as opposed to law: 2nd mile, woman. Year - real attitude, outcome of inner attitude.		In J. position we see a free person naturally acting ____ -- as opposed to law: 2nd mile, woman. Year - real attitude, outcome of inner attitude.
Line 236:		Line 248:
	Who do men say I am?		Who do men say I am?

	Peter's answer, means turning fit - he sees he is being {{Page \|n°=24}} misunderstood -- + ___ into ___ aggressive policy. After the answer Peter gave the points __ “Go up to Jerusalem suffer many changes, the ___ to death. Peter {remonst} ∴ he thinks traditionally of the “Christ”. ~~Some~~ after comes the departure for Jerusalem. __ than material about “Signs of time”. {Cloud} = sign; {touch} wind blow = tent – “How cannot you see the signs of times”.		Peter's answer, means turning fit - he sees he is being {{Page \|n°=24}} misunderstood -- + ___ into ___ aggressive policy. After the answer Peter gave the points __ “Go up to Jerusalem suffer many changes, the ___ to death. Peter {remonst} ∴ he thinks traditionally of the “Christ”. Soon after comes the departure for Jerusalem. __ than material about “Signs of time”. {Cloud} = sign; {touch} wind blow = tent – “How cannot you see the signs of times”.

	Cf. the Galileans (Jacob Maccabean) – unless he {refont} shall all perish. Obvious that Jesus was not looking on situation as polit. prob. leading to polit. action __ ___ an understanding of real _____ for “freedom” should have been present specially among disciples.		Cf. the Galileans (Jacob Maccabean) – unless he {refont} shall all perish. Obvious that Jesus was not looking on situation as polit. prob. leading to polit. action __ ___ an understanding of real _____ for “freedom” should have been present specially among disciples.
Line 248:		Line 260:
	“______ have ______ ______ drawn across the ____ If you think the is Caesars give it back - But I'll go on {Dermanty/Gesemany} that you do the just ____ ___ the multitude”.		“______ have ______ ______ drawn across the ____ If you think the is Caesars give it back - But I'll go on {Dermanty/Gesemany} that you do the just ____ ___ the multitude”.

	“Beware of Phar ~~__”~~ “__to the son of men”<br />		“Beware of Phar etc.” “__to the son of men”<br />
	“Be y not Rabbi” “Call no man master?		“Be y not Rabbi” “Call no man master.”<br />
	“Greatest among you will be your minister”		“Greatest among you will be your minister”
	{{Page \|n°=25}} “
			{{Page \|n°=25}} “W__ unto the S___ & Pharisians, hypocrites.”

	<u>{Karli}</u><br />		<u>{Karli}</u><br />
Line 260:		Line 273:
	Did Jesus suddenly in the trial, realize that he had {restored/relooked} something <ref> i.e. that Pilate would come out - <u>for him</u>, even thing him to power.</ref> − i.e.that Pilate _____ come out - <u>for</u> him, even bring him to power − that he {covered} come to power, + on the side of the Romans − perhaps even become Roman Emperor! Only this could stop from going on to power.		Did Jesus suddenly in the trial, realize that he had {restored/relooked} something <ref> i.e. that Pilate would come out - <u>for him</u>, even thing him to power.</ref> − i.e.that Pilate _____ come out - <u>for</u> him, even bring him to power − that he {covered} come to power, + on the side of the Romans − perhaps even become Roman Emperor! Only this could stop from going on to power.

	Did death was the way to ____ him […] clarification it was ~~instituing~~.		Did death was the way to ____ him […] clarification it was instituting.


	<u>Kenneth Muir</u> Heart 2XL message.<br />		<u>Kenneth Muir</u> Heart 2XL message.<br />
Line 269:		Line 283:
	2) Complete commitment		2) Complete commitment

	{{Page \|n°=26}}1) Not ~~_______~~ intellectual - _______ we must be clear where we differ <u>from</u> […]		{{Page \|n°=26}}1) Not ______tly intellectual - _______ we must be clear where we differ <u>from</u> […]
	a)<br />		a)<br />
	b)<br />		b)<br />

Santiago Pinault at 23:15, 20 August 2019

2019-08-20T23:15:34Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 00:15, 21 August 2019
Line 1:		Line 1:
			{{English to type}}

	__TOC__		__TOC__
	[[File:KPA 07-03, 1.jpg\|500px\|thumb\|right]]		[[File:KPA 07-03, 1.jpg\|500px\|thumb\|right]]